i have always thought bout this. is this life real or is it just a dream that some higher being is dreaming?
Why does it have to be a higher being that is dreaming... why cant it be me. You are just a figment of my imagination that outside of my interaction with you, you do not exist really. Because this is my unconscious dreamland and you cannot prove otherwise.
All of this is highly spreculative depending on the author and unproveable either way. Funny how perception and reality interact.
that is true but then yet again with all of the people in the world how can we all be in the same dream. or r we all a dream of many different higher beings. i just can not begin to think of what is beyond this world. or if there really is a great beyond.
what is a higher being and if we are its dream then that would have t o be one sadistic higher being i believe that this life is our own
we are all a part of a higher being..
this being is in all of us an all of us are the higher being.. to quote willy wonka
we are the dreamer of dreams..
how is that so. in the end the only thing we can control in our life is the ones we have around us. everything else is out of our control
control is the illusion. part of the dream
the mind of the dreamer has no control over the dream
It doesn't necessarily have to be a dream. Our "reality" could be anything - the human race could be the equivalent of a colony of ants on a whole other planet we had no idea existed. There's no way of knowing.
it is the complete dream that is crule not the dreamer the insite of the dreamers wisdom when he wakes or the understanding that the dream is only a instite a learning of what to be how to be
that might be the point of the crulety
that is true but with every thing that has happen what does it all mean in the end for the people living in this dream. do we die when he or she awakes or do we just fade away in to nothingness
when you sleep you wake .. you are still here when you die.. every thing that has happend ... has happend an can't be undone.. does it end in death.. for us ..?
only if ..sleeping ends all dreams when you wake
ok if we are but a dream and the dreamer wakes then how and why do we remember our past lives or even closer what happened the day before
fanman that is true. but with all mortals and even people like us wonder of the end of days and what is held for us on the other side. but the real ? is do we sit here and ponder this afterlife or do we deny it and continue to live in vain.
What is this reality, other than a dream for some other reality...?
if we could ever know the answer to the ? is this life real or a dream would u really want to know. and Enigma that is so true.
honestly i would hate to find out if my life was just a dream i would hate to wake up myself and findout that i am not the same person i was but then again i guess that is were our past lives come into play aswell
so yeah. what if our past lifes are nothing more then dreams of ourself this higher being is has had bout us in the past and the life we live now is the dream he or she is having now
you know you have good questions for every answer so the only thing i have to say now is what if ... there is really no good answer it will always remain a what if ? lol i cant win lol
We are real, we live, we die. But we also dream, imagine. and believe. So long as we dream and we create a world, so long as we can imagine a whole different world theres a world there, if we believe it is real it is real.
Are reality is are dream and are dream in are reality. What we think we see, we see, what we do not think we can see we do not see we do not see.
Are we some world in a greater role playing game that some thing is playing. Are we all just some character in a book?
No we are as real as we want to be, for we are human and much more.
I'd like to think, if indeed this is some sort of dream, that it is my dream. That I am possibly just a figment of someone's imagination is a little hard to think about.
However, I think we are more real than that... but I suppose reality can be relative. I consider many things "real" to me that others would think less than real - like vampires, for instance. ^.^
How can we tell? I believe that if there is some sort of higher power controlling, or at least manipulating, us, s/he/they are sadistic, or at least indifferent to our feelings - because whether or not I am "real" to them, my experiences and feelings are very real to me - the most real I could ever know.
I think we have all thought this question. My thought sometimes is this. We supposedly have our lives flash before our eyes at the moment of death. What if all that we percieve to be reality is just a memory of our lives. Or maybe we ARE the construct of another entity. Either way, it's all perception. But if you are feeling daring enough, do whatever it is you've always wanted to do. Whether it be kill, maim, fly. And see how real things get.
Well to me unfortunately this life is no dream, looking at the world today, I would not say this was a dream, but a ongoing nightmare full of death, decay and destruction. If this is what a higher being wants to dream then so be it I want out of it...
Thank you Enigma.
Your words reflect my thoughts.
A dream is just as real as this life when it is in motion.
the australian aborigines believe this is the dream time..
i have pondered that question for ages...there is a great movie out there called the 13th floor it depicks us in a computer and all the degarviews etc etc is a contection into another computer system....even sliders depicked we r paraell plans with everyone co-exsisting, who nows wat it is but there has to be some reason
The Matrix movies pondered this question. And we really won't know the answer until we die, but if it is all a deam, then when will we know when we wake up? It's kind of like trying yo find an exact answer to the mathematical question of what is Pi. It goes on till infinity.
Well if's some one elses dream please tell them wake up. Sorry. I have wondered that myself many times and I still have not come up with an answer. When life is hard it would be nice to think that it is all just a very bad dream in some one elses mind. But until I am proven wrong I would have to say that the life I have is real. But then again reality is what you make….or some thing like that.
this is a question i have always thought about!
i guess, like, how do you know if something is real or not? it might all be a dream
Well they do say that dreaming is real and being awake is dreaming :)
i think that it is all a dream thought up by alot of people...there is no higher beign...we all just live the dream...and yeah seven it does..
but with all of that said. can this life be real. they talk bout there being this mersiful god who is loving. but then allows all of this death and chaos to reign upon the world i think not. i think this life is a very bad night mare and has flashes of hope emmbeded in them to keep us happy. but either way how can live if we can not see what has made us this way today.
I dont believe in god but in his defense...Why is there such misery/death as you said...Well, right now we have a medium of happiness and sadness, if we only had happiness, how would we learn to appreciate, or know what it is? We have to have sadness, or we wouldnt appreciate happiness.
& we have to die, to make room for the newer generation, if we didn't it'd get overcrowded in a hurry.
that is true. but every day that me and my loved ones and my friends go on we see and feel like this life is a cruel dream and that we are puppets on strings of the dreamer. but what if that there is no afterlife there is no higher being and this is has all been a dream what happens to us when the hour glass runs out of sand for us.
i've wondered that too. like, what if there is just one person who controls everything (no not god) just, like we're a very long dream? or, what if we're already in heaven or hell (another godly thing, but still, like i said in a different forum, i talk about that at certain times)
we XT that is something that i have ponder my whole life and all of my past lifes. what is really there and what is all a dream. it is impossible to see where the dream ends and the reality of our life begins.
Ty Sevenn i was thinking of Queen as i was reading this
lol hey hells. how can this life be nothing more then the dream of a mad man when u see all of the death and the ways these souls die.
that makes sence but put this on for size. what if after this dream there is nothing else no more dreams no more life just nothingness and all of our life all of our hopes and all of our futures fades in to the darkness never to be obtained.
I believe its real, if they is all an dream......i think its to complex to be a dream.
Life is a bitch, then you die. If you feel you're a puppet on strings maybe it's because you dont feel in real control of you're life...This world is cruel but I always feel in control of my life, I dont feel like a "puppet on strings" as you say, whatever I do is because it's what I want, and I can honestly say I have not one regret
thats all well and good but how do we really know we r in control when we know not what will happen the next day.
Whats the point in living if you know whats going to happen the day after?
I make my own decisions & so does everyone else...
i think this is the real life... i doubt the someone would dream of me sitting here on vampire rave.
who is to say what the intent of the dreamer is maybe the dreamer is the reason why we are all meeting each other here, to prove that at the core of it all we all truly belong together
that is true. but if the dreamer's intent was for us to meet every one here on vr then why not do it back then why now....
i dotn know sometimes when things get crappy i think about this has to bea dream espically with disavioue, but then i think this is real
Well, I don't think it is a dream. To me, life can be more like hell. Then when I die, it might be like a dream. No one knows for sure.
This is real life. Trust me, it does not get any more real than this. If this life was a dream, don't you think it would have like happy endings for everyone?
but in the end when we die there is no happy ending what if there is only more hell for us. and even more suffering. the only one that can ever the riddle is the wheels of fate and i hate to say it but they are not talking.
thank u x. the other thing is that if this life is real how do u explain all of the things that have no explaintion for, like ufo's, crop circles, and all of that other stuff. so how could this be real.
I've pondered about that many times. And I believe in the fact that I do not know and may never know. Still it makes for a good question to ask just to get people thinking.
yes it does. just like the ? which came first the chicken or the egg
that is true. but the other thing that this brings to my mind is the reason this world of ours so messed up today cuz of a mad man that be the dreamer of this world and if so how do we wake him up to end the suffering of the victims
I have often thought the same way only I have always wandered more along the lines that we are in a coma or something of that ilk and when we die here then we wake up there. Strange I know.
From Blood Tu Bones
~Amanda~
Well if I am dreaming this, then someone wake me up. Because I don't think I would want dream this life. So, I am figuring it's pretty real.
how true every one. i have thought that too. that when we die here we wake up there and look at what we have done
I've thought about this before as well! It's like what if none of this is real? Am I dreaming? Is someone else dreaming? Will I wake up if I die? Can I die truly? Then I think, does anything matter if this is a dream?
i know that feeling all to well. i have that feeling deep with in me that something is not right bout this world and then every time i look at it i can not see past the dream or i should say the dreamers dream
I always believed that we dream but I don't really know if we dream we are living. If we are, why haven't we woken up? Is this just a dream in a dream? I don't know. It's really intriguing but noone really knows.
To be in a dream, that you cannot control, does it make us any less important, is death the end of the dream, a pathway to our desires and fantasies, that which are dreams.
I beleive its all in the opinion but, I dont beleive we are in a dream.
Personally, I think this life is as real as it gets. Or better, as real as you make it.
Some people do live in a dream of their own, neglecting their life entirely, whether by choice or not.
life is always a dream. when u look at the ur future what is it at that time a dream. so how hard is it to believe that we live inside of a dream of a higher being.
Well, if this life is someone's dream, I would have to say that this person is just a little bit sadistic. I mean, look around us, don't you think.
It would be nice if it was just a dream, for me I would just wake up and start all over when you get hurt, in pain or a bad news.
I guess we'll never know if we are living or just a part of someones dream.
But personally i think this life is ours and we are actually livng rather than being part of a dream.
I can remember discussing this once with my English teacher (yes, i had an ace English teacher). She was talking about what about if what were was dreaming was the real world, and what he percieved to be the real world was actually our dreams?
I don't know about anyone else, but I have had some very strange and random 'dreams'- so the real world, following this theory, must be a scary place!
Morganx
Ah, the butterfly that dreams of being human or is it the human dreaming of being a butterfly?
Poke yourelf with a stick and find out. There should be one laying around here some place...
if it is a dream someone wake me up, i am so sick of this nightmare
I like the idea of life being a dream, it opens up the idea of everything being possible, so long as you strive for it at least. though i am farely aware that is not particularly entirely true, it is a nice feeling.
Either way, i think it would be an ideal world if it was a dream, not a nightmare.
Illianos.
yes it would but at times if this was a dream it would cause the person having it to wake up in fright. it is a great theory life being a dream
Hum it could be either or if you wish to confuse your self further how about this life and this world just being part of a game like chess being played by someone else somewhere
well i feel like somethings in this world can't be happening it has to be a dream , because everthing around can not alll be explained.
I would have to say that this is real because there are times in life that have been too painful; that we thought we wouldn't live through. Yet we did. If it had been a dream, we would have woken ourselves up. That's how dreams work.
life isnt a dream. because everyone has a different veiw of things, people meet new people and remember that person. if everything was a dream everyone would look different every time you see it. and how would you explain our dreams?
Maybe it isn't even a higher being, maybe eacho one of us are figments of ones own imagination. I've thought about this as well. Maybe we are all sleeping and interacting through our dreams..it is highly probable..but better to go with the flow than have to think of scientific explinations and such.
I could take either side on this behalf. In my own opinion, "life" is real, just as dreams are. You have them almost every night, so why are they not real? Sure, you can't physically do or return back to your dreams, but they still happened.
It all depends on a persons perspectives.
The old" I think therefore I am" type of discussion.One only knows at the time of death.
I think that for some this life is real and for others like me this life is just something a higher being is dreaming.
in this life yes we are all peices of a bigger dream interacting with each other. but thats as far as that goes. what if we are nothing more then a mere speck in the cosmos floating around in some higher being's mind.
I like this poem about life is a dream and thought I would share it with you all..
FROM 'LIFE IS A DREAM'
by: Pedro Calderón de la Barca (1600-1681)
We live, while we see the sun,
Where life and dreams are as one;
And living has taught me this,
Man dreams the life that is his,
Until his living is done.
The king dreams he is king, and he lives
In the deceit of a king,
Commanding and governing;
And all the praise he receives
Is written in wind, and leaves
A little dust on the way
When death ends all with a breath.
Where then is the gain of the throne,
That shall perish and not be known
In the other dream that is death?
Dreams the rich man of riches and fears,
The fears that his riches breed;
The poor man dreams of his need,
And all his sorrows and tears;
Dreams he that prospers with years,
Dreams he that feigns and foregoes,
Dreams he that rails on his foes;
And in all the world, I see,
Man dreams whatever he be,
And his own dream no man knows.
And I too dream and behold,
I dream I am bound with chains,
And I dreamed that these present pains
Were fortunate ways of old.
What is life? a tale that is told;
What is life? a frenzy extreme,
A shadow of things that seem;
And the greatest good is but small,
That all life is a dream to all,
And that dreams themselves are a dream.
This English translation by Arthur Symons of Calderón's "From 'Life is a Dream'" is reprinted from Hispanic Anthology: Poems Translated from the Spanish by English and North American Poets. Ed. Thomas Walsh. New York: G.P. Putnam's Sons, 1920.
If this is a dream,like others i want out, The matrix how quaint. I dream that intwines with others of this Decay planet. I believe we are our own dreamers of the future and the past. no other Being. like Zues who greeks believed determined every hour of their live. No Wake me Up.
As I just wrote on another thread the quantum physicists believe that you can't have a universe without mind entering into it. Even when you are sleeping you mind is going. It doesn't stop!
If they are right then you directly create your life even through your dreams
I think that you make a good point My Lord Fangor. We are all part of a collective reality. Have you ever watched the movie: The Waking Life. I recommend it highly!
Does this really matter or is this question more of a "what if" kind of question. Bottom line does not change with life, dreams etc.
We all have the opportunity to lean and expand our thought process. Just because a book is not real, does not mean it cannot teach people basic lessons that they can use to enrich their lives.
So regardless of real or no, I will continue as I am on the search for becoming more than what I started with.
i have thought that to but every day i seem to come back to the same thing how could this life be real
If this is all a dream then its one crazy dream! We cant all be living in this dream..its not possible.
what if we r not really all living the same dream but are single parts of a biger dream that is being dreamt by a higher being