.
VR
Atlantis: Myth or Reality?
General Discussion
•  General Discussion Home  •   Forums Home  •



Kontradiction
Kontradiction

No Longer Registered
22:28:36 May 12 2008
Read 1,219 times





(As sourced from Pantheon.org):
**********************
Atlantis: the Myth

by Alan G. Hefner
The story of the Isle of Atlantis first occurs in Plato's two dialogues the "Timaeus" and the "Critias." Plato's story centers on Solon, a great Greek legislator and poet who journeyed to Egypt some 150 years earlier. While in the Egyptian city of Sais Solon received the story of Atlantis from priests. The priests respected Solon's reputation and cordially welcomed him. They also respected the Athenians, whom they regarded as kinsmen, because they believed their deity Neith to be the same deity as the Greeks called Athena. Therefore, she was believed to be the patroness and protector of both Greece and Egypt.
The story that the priests told Solon was unknown to him. According to ancient Egyptian temple records the Athenians fought an aggressive war against the rulers of Atlantis some nine thousand years earlier and won.
These ancient and powerful kings or rulers of Atlantis had formed a confederation by which they controlled Atlantis and other islands as well. They began a war from their homeland in the Atlantic Ocean and sent fighting troops to Europe and Asia. Against this attack the men of Athens formed a coalition from all over Greece to halt it. When this coalition met difficulties their allies deserted them and the Athenians fought on alone to defeat the Atlantian rulers. They stopped an invasion of their own country as well as freeing Egypt and eventually every country under the control of the rulers of Atlantis.
Shortly after their victory, even before the Athenians could return home, Atlantis suffered catastrophic earthquakes and floods until it disappeared beneath the sea. All of the brave men were swallowed up in one day and night of horror according to legend. This is why the Egyptians were ever grateful to the Athenians.
Also in the story Plato gives is a history of Atlantis that shows how the rulers eroded to such a state were they wanted to conquer everyone. This history had been recorded by Solon in notes that were handed down through his family.
According to Solon's notes the history of Atlantis began at the beginning of time. It was then that the immortal gods divided the world among themselves and each ruled their proportion. The god Poseidon received Atlantis, an island larger the Libya and Asia combined. He chose for a wife the mortal woman Cleito, and with her begun the royal family of Atlantis.
Poseidon built Cleito's home on a high hill at the very center of the island. The home overlooked a fertile plain bordered by the sea. For his beloved wife's protection Poseidon surrounded her house with five concentric rings of water and land. He carved the rings with the ease and skill of a god. He made hot and cold springs come from the earth. With the development of a future city his descendants never lacked for water.
Cleito bore Poseidon ten sons, five sets of boys. Atlas the first son of the first set of twins, was made king over the vast territory by his father. His brothers were appointed princes and each ruled over a large section of the territory that was distributed to him. The most valuable section of the kingdom remained his mother's home on the hilltop and the land surrounding it. This was given to Atlas. Atlas himself had many sons with the succession of the throne always passing to the eldest son.
For generations Atlantis remained peaceful and prospered. Almost all of the population's needs were met from the island's mines, fields and forests. Anything that the kingdom did not produce was imported. This was possible because a channel was eventually built which transversed all the rings from the ocean to the center of the kingdom, or the acropolis. On this stood the royal palace near the original home of Poseidon and Cleito. Each succeeding king tried to out do his predecessor in building a greater kingdom. Finally the splendid city Metropolis and the outer city of Atlantis existed behind a great outer wall.
Poseidon sat down laws for Atlantis that the rulers were to fellow. The ruling body was to meet regularly. It was to consist of ten rulers that represented the first rulers -- Atlas and his nine brothers -- who reigned with absolute power of life and death over their subjects. These meeting occurred in the temple of Poseidon where the first rulers inscribed the laws on a pillar of orichalcum. First, as required by ancient ceremony, pledges were exchanged. Then a sacred bull was captured and killed. The body was burned as a sacrifice to the god. Then the blood was mixed with wine and poured over the fire as a act of purification for each man. The rulers were served wine in golden cups, each poured a libation over the fire and swore by oath to give judgment according to the inscribed laws. When ending his vow each drank his wine and dedicated his cup to the temple. This was followed by a dinner that preceded the rulers putting on magnificent blue robes in which they judged matters concerning the kingdom according to Poseidon's laws.
As long as they judged and lived by Poseidon's laws they and the kingdom prospered. When the laws began to be forgotten trouble began. More of the rulers eventually began marrying mortals and started acting like foolish humans. Soon pride overtook the rulers who soon began grasping for greater power. Then Zeus saw what had happened to the rulers. They had abandoned the laws of the gods and acted in an evil coalition as men. He assembled all the gods of Olympus around him and was to pronounce judgment on Atlantis. This is where Plato's story stops.
Whether Plato intended to end his story of Atlantis so abruptly or whether he intended to extend it no one knows. Just as no one knows whether Plato believed in the real existence of the island or whether it was purely a mythical kingdom. Many have said they believe that Plato believed in the island's existence because he exerted so much detail in its description, while others reject this by claiming since the story was purely fiction Plato could put in as much detail as he wanted, it does not prove a thing. Also in doubt is the time period of the story. Solon writes the island existed 9000 years before. This would place the time period in the Early Stone Age. In this period it is hard to imagine the type of agriculture, architecture and sea navigation as described in the story. One explanation for this time period inconsistency is that Solon misinterpreted the Egyptian symbol for "100" for "1000." If this be the case then Atlantis would have existed 900 years before. This would place the Atlantians in the Middle Bronze Age where they would possess the tools and equipment needed for the development described within the story.
To collaborate this 900 year theory there is geological evidence showing that roughly about 1500 BCE there was a gigantic volcanic eruption which caused half of the island to sink into the sea. Also a lost city has been said to have sunk in the Bay of Naples. At the time several rich and luxurious seaside resorts were located in the area. In the retelling of the story of Atlantis it is easy to see how one of these cities could be associated with it. The story is still being told which enthralls hundreds, as archaeological digs are conducted to unearth evidence of the real Atlantis. Until then the myth remains......

***************

My Question is this: Do you think that Atlantis really existed, or was it simply Myth?







•  REPLY  •


dabbler
dabbler
Venerable Sire (130)
Posts: 11,418
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Vampire Rave member for 18 years.
23:09:53 May 12 2008
Read 1,219 times

Myth with a likely foundation in exceptable notional theory, If a civilization so advanced in engineering had the knowledge to build such things as claimed by those that persue the ledgen then would it follow that they should have known as well that building on an unstable ocean shelf would be a bad idea, if you look at some of the original cleared foundations in greece you would see that they abandoned some more sites previous to the final placements. Some cultures and travelers used
markers to show landing sites for expititions these have been claimed (and even caused division in the atlantis theorist) to be proof of atlantist. Aristotal
told children a story and wow what a tale.



•  REPLY  •


FelixFelix
FelixFelix
Sire (103)
Posts: 1,420
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Member of The House of La Bella Oscuridad
Vampire Rave member for 20 years.
23:41:35 May 12 2008
Read 1,219 times

I don't think it's entirely necessary to post the whole article from another site. I appreciate the desire to be thorough but perhaps just linking to the article or posting a portion of it would be a good way to insure that the thread maintains a more clear intent.

I have posted in the past on Atlantis and I still believe it entirely possible that Antartica has a history about it and about mystery surrounding previous ancient maps of it that make me believe this could indeed be the missing Atlantis of mythology.



•  REPLY  •


Airianna
Airianna
Sire (102)
Posts: 650
Honor: 39
[ Give / Take ]
The Coven of Hellhounds is a member of an Alliance

Member of The Coven of Hellhounds
Vampire Rave member for 19 years.
23:47:49 May 12 2008
Read 1,219 times

I believe it was there at one time, not a big as some say, I've seen hows on finding pots and other things were the city would have been.



•  REPLY  •


caustic
caustic
Hellhound (70)
Posts: 17
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Member of The Coven of Purgatory
Vampire Rave member for 21 years.
00:01:28 May 13 2008
Read 1,219 times

The Atlantis we know today has never existed. As in nearly every other legend, word of mouth has thrown "Atlantis" completely off truth and point.



•  REPLY  •


ladydragon423
ladydragon423
Ophidian (66)
Posts: 0
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Limbus Patrum (Coven) is a member of an Alliance

Member of Limbus Patrum (Coven)
Vampire Rave member for 20 years.
00:40:01 May 13 2008
Read 1,219 times

I believe that it existed and may now be at the bottom of the ocean, or even more possibly is under the ice caps. Who is to say? There are still plenty of mysteries in this world. All of Science is not a proven fact. A lot of it is speculation. We may someday yet discover the true Atlantis.



•  REPLY  •


PandorasBx
PandorasBx
Royal Sire (209)
Posts: 2,216
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Vampire Rave member for 18 years.
00:42:18 May 13 2008
Read 1,219 times

While the story is based on a myth I still believe that it is a possibility since we do know that a volcano's and/or glaciers have been a huge part of what has shaped our continents to be as they are today. Why couldn't they envelop a civilization as well.



•  REPLY  •


Kontradiction
Kontradiction

No Longer Registered
00:45:18 May 13 2008
Read 1,219 times

indeed, and this is also what i believe....a Pompeii-like situation, only involving the total "eclipse" of said Atlantis, pushing it deep under the sea as the plates realigned and swallowed it whole.



•  REPLY  •


wensala
wensala
Primogenitor (99)
Posts: 26
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Letchworth (Coven) is a member of an Alliance

Member of Letchworth (Coven)
Vampire Rave member for 19 years.
00:49:53 May 13 2008
Read 1,219 times

We once believed that the Mycenaean culture and the Island of Create were were Greek myths written by Plato to entertain... But when archaeologist uncovered the artifacts of these advanced cultures the myth became fact. If theses cultures were written about and latter discovered it seems quite pl usable that Plato's stories of Atlantis are based in reality.... We just haven't uncovered it yet.



•  REPLY  •


Kontradiction
Kontradiction

No Longer Registered
00:52:07 May 13 2008
Read 1,219 times

indeed, and i hope that someday we do find something more "concrete". the ocean is a deep and vast place, with many parts deeper than we could go right now with our existing technologies. i hope that in the future as technology grows, that we might find something to prove this fantastical "tale".



•  REPLY  •


SireZombie
SireZombie

No Longer Registered
01:13:59 May 13 2008
Read 1,219 times

alot of people tend to think it is a Myth yet, I would hope it to be real, I mean there are alot of ancient civilizations out there that is still being unearth/found so I feel it is or could be real..



•  REPLY  •


sweetblooded
sweetblooded
Sire (100)
Posts: 490
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Vampire Rave member for 18 years.
01:16:40 May 13 2008
Read 1,219 times

I think it is a very possible story the earth is always shifting and you never know what may happen to islands being build and moving as the plates below the earth shifts.



•  REPLY  •


LumiyaOfTheSith
LumiyaOfTheSith
Iconoclast (93)
Posts: 0
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
The House of Umbrae Octo is a member of an Alliance

Member of The House of Umbrae Octo
Vampire Rave member for 19 years.
03:06:46 May 13 2008
Read 1,218 times

Most probably a myth but I'd like to think there was such an island. So much written on it, TV documentaries, endless reading online for it. The Greeks talked about it.. and the Atlantic ocean was named for this mythical island.

There is another lesser known mythical island called Mu.



•  REPLY  •


dabbler
dabbler
Venerable Sire (130)
Posts: 11,418
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Vampire Rave member for 18 years.
03:07:50 May 13 2008
Read 1,218 times

As a motive for those that speculate on atlantis I chase it back to not only book sells but also, believe it or not, a lot of grant money from the coffers of university funds, .. even after for three years in a row a leading atlantis theorist supplied nothing but various reinterpitations of pending archiologist finds. In the process he drained the coffers of those very digs. Hows that for motive to pursue a myth?



•  REPLY  •


JackofSpades83
JackofSpades83
Sire (108)
Posts: 374
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Vampire Rave member for 19 years.
03:50:17 May 13 2008
Read 1,218 times

I think that most things of this nature have at lease some basis in fact.

One thing that I always took into account was that most of the old stories talk about how advanced the civilization was. Well, if you look at the time period in which the original stories were written it doesn't necessarily mean that they were capable of nuclear power, or even the combustion engine for that matter. The stories come from a long, long time ago. So, something we take for granted could have easily be seen as a technological wonder in that time period.



•  REPLY  •


dabbler
dabbler
Venerable Sire (130)
Posts: 11,418
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Vampire Rave member for 18 years.
04:10:14 May 13 2008
Read 1,218 times

Charles Berlitz was the name of the guy I believe.



•  REPLY  •


dabbler
dabbler
Venerable Sire (130)
Posts: 11,418
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Vampire Rave member for 18 years.
04:29:41 May 13 2008
Read 1,218 times

I go in looking for an agenda. the guy pocketing money usally stands out from the academics, usually because they put out a book every time they have a revelation about their unsupported theories. But fiction released as non fiction pays better then fiction. Because if you copy a work of fictions idea it is graft plagerism, but to lead people to believe such a place exist is a "quest" that people will pay grant money for as well.



•  REPLY  •


dabbler
dabbler
Venerable Sire (130)
Posts: 11,418
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Vampire Rave member for 18 years.
04:58:54 May 13 2008
Read 1,217 times

Critias and Timaeus a utopian fable from plato, I said aristotle .. my bad.



•  REPLY  •


xMitsix
xMitsix
Illusionist (78)
Posts: 232
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Limbus Patrum (Coven) is a member of an Alliance

Member of Limbus Patrum (Coven)
Vampire Rave member for 18 years.
05:08:03 May 13 2008
Read 1,217 times

I remember watching something about how some scientists believe that Cuba may be the last remaining part of Atlantis that is above water.
So I believe



•  REPLY  •


Whispersinthewind
Whispersinthewind

No Longer Registered
05:43:35 May 13 2008
Read 1,217 times

Well, as Felix pointed out...Antarctica is an excellent theory...

I still stand by mine as it being a few miles off the coast of Florida, as being around the Burmuda area. This may explain why the true north of the compass always finds its way here.

Could explain the reason why marble oblisks and ruins are found that far out to sea as well.



•  REPLY  •


Isis101
Isis101
Venerable Sire (134)
Posts: 3,054
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
The House of Lunazure is a member of an Alliance

Member of The House of Lunazure
Vampire Rave member for 18 years.
08:36:49 May 13 2008
Read 1,217 times

I believe most myths have some basis in fact. For years, people wanted to know if the flood of Noah really happened - there are flood stories from all over the globe. And recent archaeological excavations in the Black Sea have shown that there was a vast flood with changes in the sealife (from fresh water to salt water) that took place there. And there was also an ancient shoreline underneath the present one. So i say yes - there must have been something that happened to get the stories started.



•  REPLY  •


Whispersinthewind
Whispersinthewind

No Longer Registered
09:39:57 May 13 2008
Read 1,217 times

Cross referencing the "great flood" with the "Atlantian mythos", could be a good reason why the city sank in the first place. Who knows how far the flood actually traveled. Scientists apparently do not know if the flood was on a global or continental scale.



•  REPLY  •


GothsonDemon
GothsonDemon

No Longer Registered
13:05:05 May 13 2008
Read 1,217 times

Well my analysis says its a truth.
Civilizations changes very fast, geeographies and boundaries changes very fast, but tales do not take place without the truth,
Take an example of Vlad III he was truely impaler. he did such a agression that his protected area lure in love of him. and other treat him fierce vampire. If he would not be an important person of history, his portrait would not kept as most precious in the Vienna's International Musiem.

Like wise if Atlantis was not truth and Thera was not there, how the Atlantis took place on map and Thera in civilizations, communities and skills?

Its all true its not lie king kong of picture or draculla of pictures.



•  REPLY  •


GothsonDemon
GothsonDemon

No Longer Registered
13:09:28 May 13 2008
Read 1,217 times

Its not came first from teh mouth of plato, plato said all on the basis of that time coven and therian community peepal was there.

It was a big Empire and whole Europe was led by it.



•  REPLY  •


GrieviousDemon
GrieviousDemon
Premiere Sire (129)
Posts: 763
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Vampire Rave member for 20 years.
14:14:40 May 13 2008
Read 1,217 times

Since actually searching the ocean is still in its early exploration we may not find out the truth until we are long gone and our childrens children find the technology to seek further depts.



•  REPLY  •


alixaryon
alixaryon
Nightmare (97)
Posts: 786
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Limbus Patrum (Coven) is a member of an Alliance

Member of Limbus Patrum (Coven)
Vampire Rave member for 20 years.
14:16:26 May 13 2008
Read 1,217 times

It is sure that Atlantis existed, beacuse every "Myth" wich humans cultivate trough ages is in reallity a true fact, but thanks to the incorrect pass trough years from generation to generation, the more precise version of the story got considerably changed in tale it self wich is being told(it is the human nature to tell a story differently every time, for his mind was not present there exactly when it happend, or he was but doesnt remember any more precisely, wich leads to a different story to different extent of the content of that story, most important he heard it from somebody/where else), and of course that is what makes what we call a Myth, a incorrect tell tale information to believe of something that happend, but was forgotten, and it became a fairy tale in the minds of the new generations wich cant imagine other things as possible thanks to their own ways of extremly altered life styles, and culture, wich when compared with some ideas in a certain Myth story simply do not make any sense to the todays mind wich calls all that ridicilous, and a very good bed time story. Another reason why it is called a Myth, only.

I personaly believe that Atlantis very well existed, now how much the things are overexagurated or not in many versions of the Myth I really do not know, and does it matter?

We could simply go by logic, and understand that such thing existed, and its inhabitors had much more knowledge than we have for what is to us incredible, and to create it.

Logic tells us thanks to the historical facts that many civilisations existed well before us, and why not they be modern? Incredible? More incredible than us?

After all we are not the ones wich started the existence, or the first movements of it. It existed long time before us, and our interpretation of the world, wich is anyway limited.

It is clear by all the version of the Atlantis Myth, that some certain Societies Existed Before, and they were in some certain dissagreement, wich eventualy resulted of course, in one annihilating another, by some superior developed means, wich is very natural behavior troughout human history, and the future.

As well I believe that much of the truth is hidden from us, the plain folk wich makes todays society. Much things are concealed. Many truths, many stories, including the one truth about ever questioning topic of Atlantis as well.



•  REPLY  •


Dragonrouge
Dragonrouge
Great Sire (115)
Posts: 417
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Vampire Rave member for 19 years.
15:00:37 May 13 2008
Read 1,217 times

Atlantis was an Utopic land and it was Plato`s way of presenting a perfect society for his greek citizens.
Blavatski and later Himmler used it too.
I like Lovecraft`s tale based and Jules Verne`s desription in one of his extraordinary novels but it`s only a tale unfortunately.
I have read Plato`s tale and like 6 books on that subject, both pro and against.

However it`s possible that the tale was inspired by some cataclism or an old story, but Plato modified it to obtain a moral tale.



•  REPLY  •


alixaryon
alixaryon
Nightmare (97)
Posts: 786
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Limbus Patrum (Coven) is a member of an Alliance

Member of Limbus Patrum (Coven)
Vampire Rave member for 20 years.
15:15:38 May 13 2008
Read 1,217 times

I do not see the reason to state your self in such a strong fashion based only on your personal opinion Dragonrouge, wich in reality does not possess any sufficient proof, or even reality based idea, by wich it could realisticly support such a strong conclusive statement regarding the Atlantis island.

In the matter of fact the archeological underwater ruins speak just differently.

They tell a tale of ancient civilisation, wich did existed once, and dissapeard under the ocean surface.

The texts and the archeological findings, I believe lead us to that conclusion, with logic of things, that something like the island of Atlantis did existed.

Although we do not know what and how exactly, it did existed.



•  REPLY  •


Oceanne
Oceanne
Noble Sire (160)
Posts: 4,490
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Vampire Rave member for 19 years.
16:53:42 May 13 2008
Read 1,216 times

Ahh Atlantis,a subject close to my heart.I believe absolutely,but where or what,we might never know..but then,who knows,we just might figure it out..hopefully in my lifetime.Either way,we disscussed this recently ,and I thought I would post the link to the thread in case anyone wanted to read it as well.

https://www.vampirerave.com/message.php?id=468103&archived=1



•  REPLY  •


LithiumInVein
LithiumInVein
Specter (43)
Posts: 0
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Limbus Patrum (Coven) is a member of an Alliance

Member of Limbus Patrum (Coven)
Vampire Rave member for 19 years.
18:47:32 May 13 2008
Read 1,216 times

I believe that it did exist sometime and maybe still does. But the Atlantis we know as a fairy tale does not exist. The ice caps and what not are still mysteries to us. There is a lot on this Earth that are still unexplored. Atlantis was very well an island probably and due to continental drift and what not was lost kinda like how Italy is sinking now. Locals probably built onto that story to make it more interesting. Seems like that's how myths start out. As old realities.



•  REPLY  •


Kontradiction
Kontradiction

No Longer Registered
20:03:35 May 13 2008
Read 1,216 times

indeed, and as the continental plates are constantly shifting, it is highly possible it sunk into, and was absorbed, by the very deep depths of the sea.



•  REPLY  •


meeper
meeper
Premiere Sire (122)
Posts: 914
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
The House of Madadh-Alluidh is a member of an Alliance

Member of The House of Madadh-Alluidh
Vampire Rave member for 20 years.
20:08:41 May 13 2008
Read 1,216 times

I am quite skeptical about the existence of a nation or island called Atlantis. The first record or mention of Atlantis comes from Plato when discussing his philosophies on states. He was not giving factual records of cities but using analogies to create a dialogue to explain his theories.



•  REPLY  •


Nirvesence
Nirvesence

No Longer Registered
00:18:56 May 14 2008
Read 1,216 times

Have you read any Zecharia Sitchin? He has written several docu-novels about not only Atlantis, but the idea that the Roman or Greek Gods may have been from another planet entirely.

"Biography and Key Ideas
Sitchin was born in Russia, was raised in Palestine, graduated from the University of London with a degree in economic history. He worked for years as a journalist and editor in Israel before settling in New York.

Sitchin, like Velikovsky and Däniken, presents a compelling and entertaining story based on belief about ancient visitors from other worlds. Zecharia Sitchin's key ideas are based on the assumption that ancient myths are not myths but historical and scientific texts. According to Sitchin, ancient Sumerian clay tablets reveal that gods from another planet (Nibiru, which orbits our Sun every 3,600 years) arrived on Earth some 450,000 years ago and created humans by genetic engineering of female apes. "



•  REPLY  •


Skjaldepigen
Skjaldepigen

No Longer Registered
00:31:19 May 14 2008
Read 1,216 times

I belive that Atlantis has existed once a long time ago. But the myth of it has been told and translated so many times that it has kinda glorified it, making it exeptional.

A location; I would have to go with the Bermuda Triangle as well. It is the closest coordinates to what I have heard, and with the findings as someone else pointed out.

I do not think that more scientific research should be done untill they have some way of finding the real coordinates, and some more sophisticated equipment.



•  REPLY  •


AmeeraBiohazard
AmeeraBiohazard
Venerable Sire (135)
Posts: 2,436
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Vampire Rave member for 19 years.
00:35:34 May 14 2008
Read 1,216 times

Well as much as I would like to believe that it is real, simply because I didn't see it. I partly believe that it is real and I partly believe that it isn't... All the stories are so facinating and interesting and it makes it seem so real but it's amazing what the imagination can do.



•  REPLY  •


Kontradiction
Kontradiction

No Longer Registered
00:38:57 May 14 2008
Read 1,216 times

old maps of its whereabouts have revealed nothing there, really, so i think that maps drew it there on "speculation" versus actual facts.



•  REPLY  •


becomethesea
becomethesea

No Longer Registered
03:59:42 May 14 2008
Read 1,216 times

Count in another Bermuda Triangle theory supporter. It would make sense to me if Atlantians had some interesting/effective technology that was lost with their island, but somehow still affects navigation tools used today.



•  REPLY  •


Thedog
Thedog
Sire (100)
Posts: 0
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Vampire Rave member for 18 years.
04:56:50 May 14 2008
Read 1,216 times

Based on my relative lack of knowledge of the myths and stories of Atlantis, I would have to say that I don't believe that if it existed that it was the grand society and culture that many stories describe it as.

I would more readily believe that it was a coastal community of some power and influence that was destroyed by an earthquake or tsunami or some other grand act of nature (like the 3 freaking hurricanes that hit me in FL a few years ago).



•  REPLY  •


Kontradiction
Kontradiction

No Longer Registered
05:49:45 May 14 2008
Read 1,216 times

i think that the bermuda triangle makes sense in a way to help tie in a "magical island" with a present-day phenom.



•  REPLY  •


Princessmommy727
Princessmommy727

No Longer Registered
05:54:57 May 14 2008
Read 1,216 times

I do believe that it existed at one time, and is probably now under the ocean. Think about it like this: in a thousand years, how much of the world we know now will probably be underwater?



•  REPLY  •


RazaelRiezen
RazaelRiezen
Great Sire (118)
Posts: 302
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Vampire Rave member for 20 years.
06:59:57 May 14 2008
Read 1,216 times

I personally have seen threads like this about 3 or 4 times. asking whether it existed would be in my opinion much better as a poll yes or no.However

I personally love atlantis talk,I believe it exists and it lies under the ring of fire. currently the only area that has yet to actually be excavated in majority of the means.Due to the instability in that region however if you do your research then the ring of fire does make a valid area to do real research for some artifact.



•  REPLY  •


Kontradiction
Kontradiction

No Longer Registered
08:28:51 May 14 2008
Read 1,216 times

that's actually a very valid point. that is one of the few areas not available to excavation.



•  REPLY  •


Jamie
Jamie
Sire (103)
Posts: 615
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Vampire Rave member for 21 years.
08:40:38 May 14 2008
Read 1,216 times

Reality. They found some stone "things" under the sea, off the coast of Florida. They are flat and could be some sort of runway or road. This is part of Atlantis they said.

A reader once told me that I lived in Atlantis and was one of the higher up Holy people. This does go along with stuff in my past life part of astro chart.



•  REPLY  •


madbeau
madbeau
Sycophant (6)
Posts: 0
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Vampire Rave member for 13 years.
10:41:55 May 14 2008
Read 1,216 times

all myth is based on some truth so i would say there was a city that was proberly advanced but i doubt is tank into the see it problery was just destroyed or they have called it someting else



•  REPLY  •


MasterEmmanuelo
MasterEmmanuelo

No Longer Registered
16:32:43 May 14 2008
Read 1,216 times

Atlantis was a real place, the dimensions, the style all is too clearly given to be a myth. How far advanced they were, their religion, where they went after their island continent sank that is where the myth begins



•  REPLY  •


karnstein
karnstein
Hellion (73)
Posts: 1,048
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Member of Wolves of Odin (Coven)
Vampire Rave member for 20 years.
18:31:33 May 14 2008
Read 1,216 times

Atlantis is a huge snowball. some Greek scolar made vague references to a lost city, and people use that to build their own dreams on. anything we can ever dream of in science fiction could have been possible long ago in Atlantis, but it is now all lost because their hubris and foolish tampering with technology destroyed them.. it's a morality tale used by Luddites who are unable to live in with the modern age. of course there are lost cities and civilisations that died long ago - lots of them, it happens all the time. but they were only more advanced than the primitive tribes they descended to, not some vast supertechnical race of scientists / wizards . they built a city, that had a centralised system of government and a pretty sophisticated social structure, possibly on a par with the Greeks or the Egyptians, and they kept slaves. that's about all is known (or thought to be known), and probably all there is to it. The Greeks were probably talking about the Mayans, or some other such people.



•  REPLY  •


RazaelRiezen
RazaelRiezen
Great Sire (118)
Posts: 302
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Vampire Rave member for 20 years.
21:20:25 May 14 2008
Read 1,216 times

those roadways near Florida has been excavated numerous times.And there has been no markings or anything referring to them being of any lost civilization.Yes it is still possible, however those were found I believe 10 years ago and unless the historians or someone is trying to keep it quiet.Then I doubt those underwater stones have to do with atlantis.



•  REPLY  •


dabbler
dabbler
Venerable Sire (130)
Posts: 11,418
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Vampire Rave member for 18 years.
21:28:39 May 14 2008
Read 1,216 times

A varied poll would be better then just yes do you believe and no do you not believe, some would perhaps check do you feel their needs to be more grant money spent on research, to guys that use that money to travel to exotic places and dig through speculative writings by other guys who once needed something achademic sounding to support their application for a grant to get money to travel on. One of them happened to be lucky enough to tag along on an actual excavation and he began to write up his interpitation before the academics tagged and labled things for study and reference. I mean if you look at the credintials of some of these people you will find a telling pattern.



•  REPLY  •


JackofSpades83
JackofSpades83
Sire (108)
Posts: 374
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Vampire Rave member for 19 years.
22:49:09 May 14 2008
Read 1,216 times

The "Road to Atlantis" or Bimini Road was actually discovered in the late 60's I believe. Edgar Cayce, a well know "psychic" said that proof of Atlantis would be found at around the same time. I just wonder which came first. The chicken or the egg?



•  REPLY  •


UTAHVAMP
UTAHVAMP
Sire (100)
Posts: 437
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Vampire Rave member for 18 years.
02:03:21 May 15 2008
Read 1,216 times

Legends often have some truth behind them, perhaps the city did once exsist, and something did happen giving the appearence that it was wipped away, and from there the stories grew into the legends they are today.



•  REPLY  •


jayyde
jayyde

No Longer Registered
03:53:48 May 15 2008
Read 1,216 times

I think that Atlantis is real, but the story has been stretched to the point where it`s all over-exaggerated. I do believe it exsisted, but not to the magnatude of the myths.



•  REPLY  •


SkeletalAnarcist
SkeletalAnarcist

No Longer Registered
10:28:26 May 15 2008
Read 1,216 times

I believe that atlantis is both a myth and realistic, I believe that atlantis was a real place that had sunk to the sea, but i believe that all the magic and other things that fictionists make up is crap.



•  REPLY  •


BRONZe
BRONZe
Dastardly Being (59)
Posts: 0
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Member of The Coven of Purgatory
Vampire Rave member for 18 years.
10:42:54 May 15 2008
Read 1,216 times

(sorry) Whos to say that Atlantis was built on higer ground in its prime and do to the earth ever changing climate earthquakes etc that is way the city is known to underwater



•  REPLY  •


EverythingGoesSour
EverythingGoesSour
Apparition (36)
Posts: 0
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Limbus Patrum (Coven) is a member of an Alliance

Member of Limbus Patrum (Coven)
Vampire Rave member for 20 years.
10:46:38 May 15 2008
Read 1,216 times

I would say that Atlantis was probably real, but nothing like what everyone wants to make it out to be. It was probably a fairly "advanced" civilization, but I use that term lightly. Its much more likely that the stories just became widely exagerated(obviously) as time went on.



•  REPLY  •


Oceanne
Oceanne
Noble Sire (160)
Posts: 4,490
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Vampire Rave member for 19 years.
15:11:47 May 15 2008
Read 1,216 times

http://www.csicop.org/sb/2001-09/atlantis.html



•  REPLY  •


heimdalls
heimdalls
Shaitan (64)
Posts: 40
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Limbus Patrum (Coven) is a member of an Alliance

Member of Limbus Patrum (Coven)
Vampire Rave member for 20 years.
22:24:25 May 15 2008
Read 1,216 times

I firmly believe that every myth and legend is based on some form of truth, be it slightly warped/ romantised for the masses.

So yes i do believe that at one point Atlantis has existed.



•  REPLY  •


ShadowSpell
ShadowSpell
Premiere Sire (122)
Posts: 1,770
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Chateau Orleans (Coven) is a member of an Alliance

Member of Chateau Orleans (Coven)
Vampire Rave member for 19 years.
22:39:00 May 15 2008
Read 1,216 times

I believe that Atlantis is reality. The story is believable. It was destroyed be floods and earthquakes and volcanoes, not hard to believe that.



•  REPLY  •


UTAHVAMP
UTAHVAMP
Sire (100)
Posts: 437
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Vampire Rave member for 18 years.
22:47:55 May 15 2008
Read 1,216 times

Very true as per many cities where destroyed by the force of nature over the ages.



•  REPLY  •


catseye
catseye
Unregenerate (63)
Posts: 603
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Member of The Coven of Purgatory
Vampire Rave member for 19 years.
23:02:08 May 15 2008
Read 1,216 times

i think its a compendium of lst civilisations destroyed over the ages before the late bronze age.



•  REPLY  •


Heartstrings
Heartstrings
Sire (107)
Posts: 2,012
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Vampire Rave member for 20 years.
23:04:33 May 15 2008
Read 1,216 times

i personally think that it has to be more then a myth cause nobody's imagination is that great to create such a place



•  REPLY  •


divinemisskat
divinemisskat
Savant (82)
Posts: 227
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Member of Wolves of Odin (Coven)
Vampire Rave member for 20 years.
23:59:30 May 15 2008
Read 1,216 times

I feel that we would all be quite mistaken to say that Atlantis did not exist, but I don't feel that it was the technological marvel that it is sometimes portrayed as.



•  REPLY  •


Phoenix
Phoenix
Premiere Sire (123)
Posts: 343
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Vampire Rave member for 19 years.
01:58:01 May 16 2008
Read 1,216 times

Well i have mix emotions on this i believe there was a civilization but nothing to the hype of what Atlantis is



•  REPLY  •


JackofSpades83
JackofSpades83
Sire (108)
Posts: 374
Honor: 0
[ Give / Take ]
Vampire Rave member for 19 years.
02:06:09 May 16 2008
Read 1,216 times

I once saw something on TV that claimed that in the very, very distant future civilization could possibly dismiss the existence of the pyramids. It was speculated that they would be decayed so much that they would be classified as a myth. Perhaps this is along the same vein.



•  REPLY  •


Kontradiction
Kontradiction

No Longer Registered
02:23:43 May 16 2008
Read 1,216 times

good point, jack...that perhaps it got so greatly decayed that it is practically non-existent now?



•  REPLY  •


Lightningsking
Lightningsking

No Longer Registered
04:30:36 May 16 2008
Read 1,216 times

I would love to see them find traces of it and to see how far they were with technology. We may even learn things



•  REPLY  •


VR System
VR System

No Longer Registered
05:15:03 May 16 2008
Read 1,216 times

This thread has been automatically closed for length.



•  REPLY  •



• • • • THIS THREAD IS CLOSED • • • •
•  Closed by VR System on May 16 2008  •

•  General Discussion Home  •   Forums Home  •

COMPANY
REQUEST HELP
CONTACT US
SITEMAP
REPORT A BUG
UPDATES
LEGAL
TERMS OF SERVICE
PRIVACY POLICY
DMCA POLICY
REAL VAMPIRES LOVE VAMPIRE RAVE
© 2004 - 2026 Vampire Rave
All Rights Reserved.
Page generated in 0.5999 seconds.
X
Username:

Password:
I agree to Vampire Rave's Privacy Policy.
I agree to Vampire Rave's Terms of Service.
I agree to Vampire Rave's DMCA Policy.
I agree to Vampire Rave's use of Cookies.
•  SIGN UP •  GET PASSWORD •  GET USERNAME  •
X