Do you think a tree, flower, or any other plant can have it's own soul? If you believe in reincarnation, do you think one can be reincarnated into a plant?
Some religions believe the answer is certainly yes, what do you think?
anything is possible,even things that seem far fetched at times can have some kind of truth to it,some eastern religions believe every object has a living soul and a purpose.
Many of HP Lovecraft stories believed in the souls of trees and tree spirits, yet a question to you is are they not living things. And for this would they not have a spirit or maybe a soul. What I believe in.
So anything living has a soul you think? Does that mean all the bacteria flying around have souls too?
Soul, no. Spirit, yes. To me they are two different things.
why would we be the only thing with a soul, or spirit. like saying we are the only intelligent life here on this world or the next, my feelings.
Souls don't equal intelligence, and just because we may not be the only ones with souls doesn't mean EVERY living creature has the right to a soul. Some living things are too puny for a soul, in my opinion.
I am not sure if I believe in them having souls per se or if they have a living entity in them. I do believe yes life forms, but perhaps not a soul. Just my thoughts is all.
Gwendolyn i seem to like your answer more than mine, maybe that is what i was trying to achieve. thanks
characteristics maybe even personality... its just... soul?
yeah ok, i have a hard time beleiving anything has a soul... so uh ... hey this isnt some april fools stunt?
People were created from seed as well as animials. Plants are also created by seed. Do we not nourish and take care of the plants we ourselves grow?
I cannot remember what Indian tribebbelieves that the spirit of their tribal members that passed on the spirit lives in the trees.
Spirits yes.
I don't know that Soul or spirit is the right word.
All of nature, all things alive in fact have their own energy.
Being that I believe in progession I would have to say no, I don't think humans are reincarnatd into plants or animals.
If it were so then that would be a backwards step in evolution of the spirit.
I believe everything should be treated as divine no matter what.
For the original question one would first need to ask for a valid definition of soul.
It believe in a soulless plant, so I guess I believe in plant that has a soul.
they have life energy to grow so i guess they can have a soul
I don't believe that every thing has a soul, like someone else before me has stated, "maybe it's own energy, but not a soul". So I do not think that any one can be reincarnated as a plant.
plants most certainly do have souls they interact with the environment around them as being brought back as one i think that falls into the matter of personal belief on weather or not you believe in that i for one feel you come back as the same person
To me they are living and my god and goddess live in everything.
The animating and vital principle in humans, credited with the faculties of thought, action, and emotion and often conceived as an immaterial entity.
soul (n.) The spiritual nature of humans, regarded as immortal, separable from the body at death, and susceptible to happiness or misery in a future state.
soul (n.) The disembodied spirit of a dead human.
As per the American Heritage Dictionary.
That said, I find it hard to believe that plants feel emotions and I do not believe in reincarnation.
I believe that plants have no souls, but they do have an energy that allows them to live.
I believe that the plants do have a soul. Every living thing on this planet has a soul. They may not have feelings like humans do but that does not mean that they do not have souls.
The definition of a soul says you DO have feelings so you are contradicting your answer.....
I certianly believe a soul has to create energy, and to grow and die. Therefore I think a plant has a spirit.
I don't know. But I do know that they "feel". I saw a show once about how trees communicate with other trees. One was being attacked by something, I can't recall what it was, but it sent out signals telling other trees to be on guard because of it, and they closed leaves more and responded. It was so cool.
It physically pains me to see trees, etc. get cut down or destroyed. Some people are idiots.
Anything is possible but do i beleive this not reaaly... It seems far catched but i could be very wrong and may change my views in the future
I think they do, but not liek ours, they are living organisms, I have a plant that actually will die overnight if you speak negatively to it, kinda weird, but very fasinating. As per a person reincarnating as a plant, I dont think so....we are differant creatures and all, but who knows anything is possible.
They also did studies where they played Mozart and other classical music for plants and they grew very well. They played heavy metal and it killed them.
Plants are smart. ;)
Very true indeed, there is something about them, maybe we could learn from plants.
I agree that trees, flowers, etc. all have souls. They're living organisms just like humans and animals. It would make perfect sense for them to have souls, especially for those who believe that if you talk to house plants or garden plants in a positive manner, they will have better chances of growing and manifesting themselves to provide beautiful foliage, fruits, etc.
Just like other people and animals, plants should be treated with respect. Always remember the three-fold rule of thumb :)
Wow, I never knew trees were that smart! Thanks for those posts you two.. they were great.
Well if plants "feel", then they certainly have souls.
I believe that anything that is living has some form of a soul. But I dont believe in reincarnation
Why would a plant have a soul? Thats like saying that anything living like the common cold has a soul. Or the flu viris has a soul. People dont believe that the cold has a soul, why would they believe that a plant does?
Because plants are a bit more.. alive than the flu? They have history, they have power. Plant life is part of human life.. viruses only kill people.
I believe that every thing that breaths moves grows or otherwise shows signs of life have a soul of sorts. a rock not so much.... but things that grow live and die i think will.... I have absolutely no proof or works cited to base this on... just personal belief
Hmm ...it depends. Usually the belief in reincarnation means you still have lessons to learn --some lessons probably wouldn't go well with being a tree or a grapevine, but who knows.
i dont no for sure but i have friends who talk to there plants and they say that helps them grow.
sawblade, thats actually quite true. My mother used to do that, she always had lots of different plants in the house wich she was cultivating and taking care of, and was practicing the same belief(if one says to that plant that it is a nice plant, it will aparently get it, and will grow better, happier. I guess it is understanding and picking up the positive vibration in a way.) so I guess it has to be a certain fact behind that practice/belief. Plants seem to have a certain sense of emotion and understanding of their own, although we cant see it so easy.
I found that always to be a funny thing to do. lol
depends what you mean by soul. all things have a spirit, but not all things have a soul. estate agents for example.
i certainly believe that a person can be reincarnated as a tree. some people believe that inanimate objects can contain the soul of a person who has died. like chucky for example. yeah, i know thats just from a film, but some people will swear blind that a car or even a chair is possessed by the soul of its former owner. some parapsychologists believe that is how a haunting works - the bricks and mortar of a house become permeated with the spirit or soul of a dead person. if bricks can contain a soul, why not a living plant?
I've thought about this before. I remember hearing once about a man who strongly believed that he was a tree in a past life. Why not, I suppose.
Too tired to think about it anymore right now though *falls over*
Yes in the Native american way, everything from a rock to a tree to the animals and human all had souls.
I blieve there is a spirit more or less in them, you can feel it when you place your hand on them. I can hear them "talk" almost. I am a earth snake so yea its easier for me to hear them, more so then someone that is fire, or water.
I believe you may have started out life as a plant when your soul was first created. I do believe plants have souls! The Aura is the energy field created by your soul... and all things have aura's unless they are an inanimate object. So for me yes plants even a blade of grass has souls.
I think I am afraid of lawn mowers because I started out as a blade of grass :P
Plants have souls? Nope.
Plants have spirits? Nope.
Plants have life force, or life energy. Yes.
I believe sentient beings are required to be able to manifest a soul or a spirit. At the moment, the plants, fungi, baterium, and plankton don't cut it.
I don't think "soul" would be the best term for it, but they most definitely have a certain life energy. Can one be reincarnated into a plant....in a sense, I suppose so. Perhaps the outflow of your personal energy when you die is recycled and could be used in the making of a plant, energy-wise....so in a sense, I'd say yes.
I dont think they have a soul. I think for something to have a soul it would need to have an opportunity to make an educated decision. Plants seem far too automatic to qualify in my opinion.
honestly, i think anything living has a spirit inside of it..it comes from my Native American Heritage....
yes I think that every living thing has a soul and that soul goes to what ever heaven it or you believe in
I believe that anything that can be destroyed has a soul of some sort.
To me I believe everything has a soul. And should be treated with respect.
I agree that all living things should be treated with respect but that doesn't mean that I think they all have a soul.
again we are getting to the difference between a spirit and a soul. a soul means free will, self determinalism, or at least a self awareness. okay, there is no way to show whether a plant has self awareness as we know it. they can react to a stimuli - but then so can a battery operated toy. that does not mean that "Toy Story" is true.
maybe a single plant has no soul - but i believe a forest can have a soul.
plants are very powerful and are used for many different things....yes i beleive that you can come back as a plant
I believe our soul is the energy that runs through us. Of course, plants are living and have energy too; so why not? ;)=
I don't think plants have a SOUL, necessarily...I mean they are undoubtedly alive and are very important things in our every day life...but I don't believe that they think, therefore, don't have a soul. To me, a soul means personality.
I don't personally think you can be reincarnated as a plant, but that's just my own opinion.
i believe in reincarnation but i dont think you can become a plant. I think if plants do have spirits the spirit is too much of a difference between that of a human and a plant.
I believe that plants do not have the mortal energy to carry a soul.
I believe in reincarnation but had never considered coming back as a plant. i do know each plant has a certain energy associated with them. A soul not sure.
I believe they do, just its wants and needs are much more simpler.
If you want to bring it back to reincarnation a plant would be a medium to tech a soul to enjoy the smaller things in life, to limit materialism, to ground someone.
I don't think it's possible for a plant ot posses a soul (no nervous system) no pain no love no hate. that sorta thing I don't bleieve in reincarnation either but I've heard others who do say that when reincanated u are reincarnated in to either another person, a bug an animal it is something that moves.
I don't know. Anything is possible. But the reason that plants respond so well to people talking to them is because they absorb the carbon dioxide that we breath out on them. Oh, I know that's not so romantic as thinking they have a soul. I think that whole life force idea is plausible. Hell, what do I know. I can't wait to die and find out....unless I get reincarnated again...
I don't think that they do. If they did, how come they don't have feelings and do they grow wild and without water? or with at least very little water
Though I find this to be a very reaching question, since both the proof that the "soul" exists and the theory of the reincarnated being a plant.
Thoughts would be very misconstrude and taken out of context when it comes to the souls play with living matter.
No, I do not believe plants have souls. I feel they have a form of connection with the rest of the world but no soul.
I believe that plants are a form of life. It is my opinion that all plants and all forms of life, no matter how obscure, have a soul.
No, I don't think that trees, plants, or any other plant like thing have individual souls. Maybe one soul, the soul of the earth but that would be it. that's my thought on it anyway.
_To me, all living things have spirits. Maybe not souls. When you think about it, what is a soul? It's a part of the person themselves, their personality. Maybe plants and what not do not have a soul, but rather a spiritual energy that is united and formed in the earth._
No. I don't believe plants have souls or spirits.
Energy, yes. But then, I believe that everything has it's own type of energy. Else it was not exist.
To me, plants are too close to an inanimate object to have anything resembling a soul and such.
Well at first, thinking that oriental teachings that a plant (or even a ARTIFICIAL OBJECT!!) could have a soul, just apeared funny to me.
Later I realized that some beings that don`t have a language that we could understand have a pretty big level of abstract intelligence (pidgeons are a good example), I begun to doubt.
Now I think that plants have a soul too.Of course thay can`t communicate.I practice the spagiric alchemy and I think that there are some forms of energy (we could call them souls) that have a high degreee of abstraction.
Interesting question. Somehow i belive everything living have somekind of a soul even plants. But not the same kind of souls as we human have.
I think plants and trees have souls but I don't think we come back as them.
thats a hard question to answer, plants are living, and living things have souls, so maybe they do or they don't
I believe in reincarnation but not to where a human would be reborn as a tree or flower. I don't think a plant or tree would have a soul like a human does, just maybe a life force energy.
Pantervamp, thank you very much for this fascinating piece of information. It is indeed astonishing. It shows so much, it shows how much we do not know.
I believe that this is as well a perfect answer to the original question; "Do you think a tree, flower, or any other plant can have it's own soul?".
It proves that the answer can be only positive, yes plants/trees/flowers have a soul, and they are so fascinating out of the reason wich is very slow to be observed by our naked casual eye.
The research proves that they do have intention, they do have fears, they do show the tendency/wish/will to preserve them selves in best condition as possible(they defend them self by adapting), not to mention the level of communication wich plants are exibiting toward their environment, and all this at the end concludes that plants are aware of their bodies, they are very well aware of their existence, they really are alive, and with that logicaly, as the living organisms/sistems, certanly they do possess a soul(as everything living does),
as the statements/conclusions of Peter Tompkins and Christopher Bird;
"Tompkins and Bird conclude, "Evidence now supports the vision that plants are living, breathing, communicating creatures, endowed with personality and the attributes of soul"
Now this is of course catapulting me back to the other part of the question; "If you believe in reincarnation, do you think one can be reincarnated into a plant?"
Believing in to the process of reincarnation of the soul back to the material world, and taking another suitable body/form, living another life in that body/form, as a mean of further learning wich should serve to the proper evolution of ones soul, leaves us at that conclusion where we understand that the answer is as well positive, that the answer is yes, that one can be reincarnated, in to a plant, or a tree, taking that body/form as its next process or learning here in this next incarnation of ones soul. It is naturaly ungraspable to many, but the soul has its own ways of learning and understanding the whole, the way it is(as the altogheter Universe does and it works/functions that way tirelessly, toward completition/perfection as a process wich we/learning souls are part of), and until it can reach that level of understanding, ones path of learning trough experience is diverse, and it will include many forms as means of development, as well one of a plant/tree/flower.
So to finaly conclude, yes, I believe it is possible, not only that I think it is possible, but I believe as well that one is about to take that path, or one already had, as a process of his own personal evolution of the soul, trough reincarnation, trough learning experiences, learning the property and correctness of things, and they way they should be, until the completition has been reached for every single soul trough learning.
They have done studies and found that when you rip a carrot from the ground it screams.. So yeah I guess they could..
I would like to think plants do, tho it may not be a soul like we think, i do belive the have energy be it positive or negitive.
i believe Pantervamp summed it up nicely i was just gonna say that when i was younger i watched a show that took shrimp in a bucket and a plant sitting next to the shrimp they hooked up a machine simular to a lie detector test theyhad it attached to the plant and when they poored hot water over the shrimp the plant went crazy the needles moved off the chart. so i believe YES
Fascintating and thanks for this thread!
Yes, plants do have souls/spirits (one and the same to me) and yes you can incarnate into one.
You can also incarnate into stones, air, light, a concept..... To trually learn all you can from physical incarnation, you must experience all.
They say plants have feeling like us or animals, and we have souls so why wouldn't plants. I believe people and animals can be reincarnated at plants, and that plants have souls. I wanna be re-incarnated as a Venus Flytrap...lol
Definatley i have grown many a plant and the indoors ons like music
yes, i believe any living thing has a certain thing as a soul, but certainly not like ours. I think when we die if we have a choice to go back as somehting else we can.